USC

New law banning ghost ticket scams not enough, music industry professionals say

California legislation passed a bill on Sunday banning the sale of speculative “ghost” tickets, but it is only scratching the surface of problems with ticket reselling.

Audience members raise their hands high to be captured in a group photo.
Fans have trouble getting tickets to concerts due to high prices on "ghost" tickets. (Photo by Laury Li)

On Sunday, California Governor Gavin Newsom signed AB 1349, a bill banning the sale of “ghost” tickets, into law.

Ghost tickets are also known as speculative ticketing, in which scalpers advertise tickets as being for resale before they actually possess them.

In July, StubHub and other ticket resale markets faced major scrutiny for being involved with promoting “ghost ticket” listings for the 2026 FIFA World Cup. Fans who paid significant sums of money for tickets were left empty-handed at the door, some of them having traveled across the country or the world to attend.

Sporting fans haven’t been the only ones affected. Concertgoers have faced similar issues throughout the years, including Taylor Swift fans who reported being subjected to speculative ticketing for the Eras tour.

Assemblyman Issac Bryan of Culver City, who proposed AB 1349, described the bill in an April hearing as legislation that “protects fans, supports artists and ensures a fair ticketing system.”

After two years of legislation, and lobbying on both sides from StubHub and Live Nation, the bill was passed.

In early September, the National Independent Venue Association expressed concerns about this new bill. “AB 1349 abdicates multibillion dollar resale platforms like StubHub from true accountability for selling ghost tickets. It puts the small businesses and nonprofits that put on shows every night at risk,” said Stephen Parker, NIVA’s Executive Director.

According to StubHub’s statement to Annenberg Media, this bill “clearly applies to resale marketplaces like StubHub,” citing sec. 22502.1(b) and sec. 22505.6(a), which both refer to “ticket resale marketplace.”

Based on the Sept. 27 edition of the bill, section 22505.6 (a) states, “It shall be unlawful for a person, ticket seller, original seller, ticket reseller, ticket resale marketplace, or other person acting in connection with the sale or resale of tickets to advertise, market, or offer tickets for sale in a manner that is likely to mislead a reasonable consumer regarding the source, sponsorship, authorization, availability, price, or nature of the ticket being offered.”

“AB 1349 bans the sale of speculative tickets, including on resale marketplaces,” said Brian Berry, Executive Director of Ticket Policy Forum in a statement. “We applaud Assembly member Bryan for enacting these consumer protections, and our members will of course comply with the speculative ticketing ban and the many other new requirements that come with this new law. ”

For some legal experts, there is skepticism on whether the law will adequately protect consumers.

“The late amendments are about making it much more difficult to sue the marketplace platforms,” said Dimitri Korovilas, founding partner of Wucetich&Korovilas and litigator with an emphasis on class action consumer cases. “Instead the problem is for the individual ticket brokers, and the problem is that it’s hard to know who those people even are.”

Andrew Leff, an associate professor at USC Thornton School of Music, founder of Acme Music and former Talent Agent for the Agency for Performing Arts, argues that the legislation isn’t strict enough.

“It’s a toothless bill that doesn’t address the fundamental issue that selling anything above 10% face value should be illegal,” said Leff. “Companies like StubHub – who lobbied heavily to maintain their exploitative and unethical practices – should be forced out of business.”

Kevin Lyman, an associate professor at Thornton School of Music and the founder of Vans Warped Tour echoed Leff in the limits for resale prices.

“No one should be able to charge more than 10% of the price,” said Lyman. “We need more transparency, and the public has so little access to tickets at a fair price.”

Ontario, Canada was the first to implement a price cap for ticket reselling sites in April in an effort to prevent price gouging. The cap is strict, including taxes and service fees.

In the United States, Maine, Vermont, and Washington, D.C. all succeeded in passing their own 10% price cap. While California attempted to follow suit, the California Fans First Act (AB 1720) died in committee.

Ticket scalping isn’t a new concept, but the rise of online marketplaces has made it a greater issue for consumers. Legislators across the U.S. have been attempting to find ways to regulate the growing prices that have arisen from issues like speculatory ticketing.

Lyman reflected on his earlier days working at venues across the nation, and how the landscape has changed in recent years, calling it the growth of “institutionalized scalping.” He said that the real issue is the larger secondary markets themselves.

“Now, with the placement of bots and institutionalized buying, they’re sucking so much of the volume [of tickets] out from the everyday fan, that we’re seeing people go to less and less shows,” said Lyman.

Korovilas said the rise of secondary markets has taken away from the art of the industry.

“It’s important to note what this industry is really about, and the fine line between what some might call smart business and what others might call a scam,” said Korovilas.

Stella Badrutt-Baer, a junior studying music industry, said she knows people who suffered from ticket reselling scams. “It’s definitely always a gamble of whether the person is going to send you the ticket in time for doors,” she said.

She doesn’t think AB 1349 goes far enough.

“It’s the company’s responsibility to have safeguards in place for this not to happen,” she said, “But I think it’s pretty hard to crack down on individuals, it’s an impossible task to get every scammer to stop scamming.”

As the bill has just been enacted, we have yet to see the legal repercussions for individuals who have been involved with selling “ghost tickets.”

Editor’s Note: The section about the new bill’s requirements for resale marketplaces has been updated following an additional fact-check of the bill’s details.

Edited by Lindsay Augustine and Leo Li