The 2027 Grammy Nominations for the Best Dance/Electronic Album and Best Dance/Electronic Recording were announced Monday and included Madonna, Fred again.., Robyn, Skrillex, Slayyyter, Tinashe, underscores and Tame Impala.
USC sophomore business administration major Mandy Wang, who previously helped open for house DJ Dom Dolla at the Fvded in the Park festival, said the nominees didn’t look like the festival lineups she knew.
“Initially, I was surprised by the lack of festival artists on the lineup,” said Wang. “While all very influential artists, the albums and songs were definitely not the first tracks that come to mind when thinking of songs that defined EDM (Electronic Dance Music) this year.”
The lists have reopened a question the Academy settled in 2023, when it created a separate award – now called Best Dance Pop Recording – through which pop stars making dance-flavored songs would no longer compete head-to-head with artists rooted in club music.
However, the separation feels vague this year, with Madonna, Slayyyter and Tinashe being nominated in both the dance pop category and the dance/electronic recording category.
The Academy’s own rules say the dance/electronic album award is meant for music “with production and sensibilities distinctly different from a pop approach.”
“I just think the issue is with the vagueness of the category itself and I do think that some of the nominees should probably not have been in that category realistically,” said Joey Del Preto, a junior studying public relations and advertising.
The most visible critic has notably been DJ and producer John Summit, who received no nominations for his recent April album, “Ctrl Escape.” In a post on X Monday morning, Summit said he would stop submitting music to the Grammys unless the categories change, adding that “the whole dance category is just music industry fueled pop stars.”
By Wednesday afternoon, the post had more than 4.2 million views, nearly 4,000 reposts, and more than 22,000 likes. Many of its roughly 1,900 replies pushed back. One of the most-liked came from Nightfeelings, a producer on Tinashe’s song “Melatonin,” who wrote, “I actually come from dance music.” That reply alone drew more than 16,000 likes.
Hours after his original post, Summit wrote that he was logging off to “continue my sold out arena tour for my real fans.”
Some USC students said Summit had reason to be frustrated, but disagreed with aiming that frustration at other artists.
“I do see his point. I don’t think he should be snubbing these other pop stars, but I see that there’s a different category for them,” said Amandine Alcantara, a junior studying international relations, who’s passionate about electronic music.
Anthony Vigil, a junior studying business administration who DJs for the Chi Phi fraternity, was more blunt.
“Other artists who weren’t nominated didn’t respond that way, and I think he needs to take a step back and realize that sold-out shows, remixes of past hits and a big personality don’t guarantee a nomination,” Vigil said.
Not every student DJ saw the post as a shot at other artists. Dan Xie, a sophomore studying business of cinematic arts who DJs for the Kappa Alpha fraternity, said Summit’s pull with fans in their 20s and 30s is the reason the complaint got attention at all.
“I think if it was said by any other EDM artist in this day and age, they wouldn’t have been taken seriously,” Xie said. He added that Summit “has every right to speak out” about not being nominated.
Much of the pushback to Summit’s post came from fans defending Madonna, whose album “Confessions II” and single “I Feel So Free” are nominated in both dance/electronic categories.
“I think it’s just in poor taste to come for any artist, because I don’t think anyone finds Madonna to be industry-fueled. She’s been a dance pop legend for decades at this point,” Del Preto said.
Madonna was the first artist to land 50 No. 1 hits on any single Billboard chart and she did it on Dance Club Songs, a ranking built on reports from club DJs. She also won the Grammy for Best Electronic/Dance Album in 2007 for “Confessions on a Dance Floor.”
Artists themselves don’t get the final say on where they compete. Instead, the Academy sets up volunteer screening committees each year that sort submissions into categories. According to the Academy, those committees don’t judge a recording’s quality. Their job is to make sure each entry is eligible and placed in the proper category.
USC student DJs said their own picks would have looked different.
“I would have liked to see John Summit be nominated, and some names like Dom Dolla and Chris Lake because I just feel like those are two artists that represent house music very well, as well as EDM,” said Dario Ghamgosar, a senior studying real estate development & architecture, who DJs for his fraternity Sigma Nu.
The winners will be announced Feb. 7 at Crypto.com Arena in downtown Los Angeles.
Edited by Leo Li and Fashion Castillo
