During an opening weekend screening of A24’s Primetime at AMC Santa Monica, the seats were jam packed, reflecting the online anticipation about the film.
Robert Pattenson shocked audiences with a vampiric portrayal of Chris Hansen during his early days on Dateline NBC’s To Catch A Predator. Pattinson led the audience through audible cheers, gasps and laughs, specifically when he has a small neurotic, eye-twitching meltdown after a snack gets stuck in a vending machine.
Reviews came in the following weeks with heavy praise on the acting and “neo-noir” style visuals.
While reclining in my red leather AMC seat, I thought that this was the kind of classic shared experience that made going to the movies an American pastime in the first place, and found it hard to believe that not so long ago, it was all threatened with extinction.
But who was the suspected killer of the movie theater?
It appeared to be streaming services, but after the mask was removed, it was revealed to really be studio executives. If you recall, after the COVID-19 lockdown began, studios and industry analysts began quickly placing their bets on the streaming economy, after hemorrhaging money at the box office.
At the time it was easier, safer and in some places, even mandatory to watch movies at home.
Big budget films that have been in the works for years were given a limited theatrical release and quickly rushed towards the top streaming networks. In December 2020, Warner Bros. announced that all 17 of its planned 2021 releases, including Dune, The Matrix Resurrections and Godzilla vs. Kong, would premiere simultaneously in theaters and on HBO Max.
Meanwhile, streaming stocks boomed, with Netflix’s share price jumping 73% from March 2020 to July of the same year.
Some predicted that the American pastime of grabbing popcorn and buying a movie ticket would eventually be dead and buried. Washington Post opinion writer Megan McArdle asked, “could Americans simply lose the habit of going to the movies, learning to get their video entertainment from streaming series and their socializing from the backyard?” in her 2020 article, Be prepared to say goodbye to movie theaters.
In March, as studios began releasing films directly to home audiences, analyst Rich Greenfield warned in The Wrap that “if it works, the world will change.”
Industry whales like Warner Brothers (now a part of Skydance) and The Walt Disney Company led the decision making in response. Disney’s streaming division, which included Disney+, Hulu and ESPN+, reported a whopping $4 billion operating loss in their 2022 financial report.
Executives would then place a massive bet on streaming, slating Disney+ shows that would fill the weekly void for the next few years.
“I remember there was a time where we weren’t sure if the theaters were gonna come back,” said Kory Chule, a manager for a movie theater in Los Angeles who has worked in the industry for six years. “I think people do crave human interaction. They can watch something and they can all laugh together and then talk about it, you know.”
Theaters themselves were also fighting to stay afloat financially, and Los Angeles was hit particularly hard.
In April 2021, ArcLight Cinemas and Pacific Theatres announced that their 17 locations would not reopen following the pandemic, including the famous Cinerama Dome in Hollywood. The company’s announcement said it did not have “a viable way forward,”.
“It’s closed because I think a lot of things closed at that time,” said Kirsten Bennett, a local teacher and a movie fan who would frequent the ArcLight. “But I used to really like going and just having that experience of the big screen.”
In October 2020, Regal announced they were shutting down all 536 of its U.S. theaters. AMC theaters reported permanent closures of 63 theaters in the same year. According to Axios, the United States had more than 2,000 movie screens shut down between 2019 and 2022.
Those permanent closures came after movie theaters were not open to the public during the COVID-19 pandemic. A change that impacted Los Angeles beginning on March 15, 2020 when Mayor Eric Garcetti announced the closure of movie theaters, bars, nightclubs and other entertainment venues to slow the spread of the virus, initially only supposed to last until March 31st.
“We need to take these steps to protect our city right now,” Mayor Garcetti said.
Theaters needed to find ways to circumvent the shifting plans from the production companies, and it was the desire for community that helped smaller theaters find their strength. According to the Los Angeles Times, independent theaters like Vidiots and American Cinematheque attracted audiences with screening older classic films, discounted tickets and Q&A events with directors and actors.
“I think the thing that streaming got wrong was that we weren’t going to adapt,” said Nick Uneputty, manager of a large theater in Santa Monica. “We started introducing, the A-List program, where you can now watch like four movies a week”
Movie theater ticket sales brought in $11.36 billion domestically in 2019, before plummeting 81.4% to $2.11 billion in 2020. But audiences eventually started coming back, albeit slowly. The total box office crawled back to $4.48 billion in 2021, and continued climbing to $7.37 billion in 2022, according to Box Office Mojo.
Some say they actually prefer the cost of going to the theater over maintaining several streaming subscriptions.
“I did a spreadsheet last year and it’s cheaper if I go to the theater than having all these streaming subscriptions,” said Sam Lupson, a USC game development student who goes to the movies almost every week.
Audiences were hungry to return to their seats, as proven by the success of the “Barbenheimer” double feature in 2023, when online momentum led audiences (myself included) to purchase tickets for Barbie and Oppenheimer on the same day. Theaters earned $8.91 billion in revenue that year. However, the comeback era has yet to reach pre-pandemic heights, with box office revenue earning $8.57 billion in 2024 and $8.66 billion in 2025.
The bigger they are, the harder they fall, and American pastimes are particularly stubborn. I wanted to find out why people are still visiting the movie theaters in 2026, and many of the moviegoers I spoke with believe there is something about the theatrical experience that streaming simply cannot replace. For them, going to the movies is a tradition worth keeping alive.
Charlie Sonnek, a USC mechanical engineering student said, “It’s the experience of going with your friends, sitting next to each other, sharing popcorn, and afterwards, just talking about it in the movie theater. Talking about how it’s so good or so bad.”
His friend Sean Kwok, a USC MFA student added, “I saw Other Mommy in theaters, right? And the movie itself was pretty bad, but we saw it in 4DX. We were rocking around in the chairs, and we were having a great time. Even though the movie was terrible, it was fun going with friends.”
“I think it just goes to show that people aren’t really done with the theater experience. They just want to go see things and movies that actually connect with them and resonate,” said Sam Marcus, who goes to the theater every week with his father, Daniel. “I don’t really like watching it from home as much. I think there’s something unique about the big screen, seeing things on a big screen in a quiet room, very dark.”
Cara Paige, an employee at the now re-opened legendary Bruin Theater in Westwood, agreed.
“You can’t get that at home, which is a special aspect of, like, everyone’s gasping or laughing or crying,” she said.
“I feel like I was raised to watch movies in a movie theater. It’s more nostalgic than anything,” said Lucci Babi, who was attending a screening of Clayface with his girlfriend.
Sofia Guadarrama, USC Sophomore in Film Production, goes to the theaters a few times per month, and buys a ticket for whatever piques her interest.
“I didn’t go to the theaters a lot as a kid, so I think I’m just kind of healing my inner child right now,” Guadarrama said.
When asked if the theater experience was dead, she wholeheartedly disagreed. Theater turnout may not have returned to its pre-pandemic financial highs, but the experience itself is far from dead.
