Arts, Culture & Entertainment

Review: Taylor Swift’s “Cleveland!” shows the problem with living through the audience’s gaze

As social media makes everyday life feel increasingly visible, Swift’s song explores how public opinion can shape self-perception. USC students weigh in.

Photo of Taylor Swift
Taylor Swift waves as she walks with Travis Kelce's father, Ed Kelce, after the AFC Championship between the Baltimore Ravens and the Kansas City Chiefs, Sunday, Jan. 28, 2024, in Baltimore. (Photo courtesy of AP Photo/Nick Wass)

In Taylor Swift’s latest song “Cleveland!,” Swift taps into a familiar feeling: spending so much time imagining what other people think that their opinions start to feel like one’s own.

Released Sept. 25, the track offers a revealing look at how public perception can shape even the most personal parts of life. Rather than simply celebrating her relationship with Travis Kelce, Swift spends much of the song imagining the people who might have something to say about it — their judgments about her appearance, her age, her desirability and the relationship itself.

She then answers those imagined critics with reassurance from Kelce: “Hate all you like, this is the love of my life.”

The result is a love song in which the audience is almost as important as the lovers. Swift isn’t just telling audiences what it feels like to be in love. She is telling them what it feels like to be in love while imagining everyone else watching.

The Audience Becomes Part of the Story

That strange dynamic is at the heart of The Guardian’s criticism of “Cleveland!” In its review, the publication points to a self-referential loop in Swift’s songwriting, noting that “for all that she laments the hater, she sure does write a lot of songs about them.” The more Swift writes about the people who criticize her, the more those criticisms become material for another song, turning the audience’s reaction to Swift into part of Swift’s next discography.

That criticism gets at what feels particularly unusual about “Cleveland!” It claims to be a love song about her marriage to Kelce, but the emotional center of the song isn’t really love. It’s anger.

Listeners have noticed that, too. The theme of perceived resentment is so prominent that it can feel almost disconnected from the romance itself. Rather than revealing what this relationship actually feels like for her, Swift is writing about how she thinks other people perceive her love.

What makes “Cleveland!” feel particularly strange is how different it is from the way Swift once wrote about love. I, for one, long for the days of “Love Story,” one of her most enduring songs. It is centered around an emotional experience: forbidden love, yearning, believing you know what’s best for you when other people disagree and defying expectations. These aren’t just engaging themes for a songwriter; they are experiences.

“Love Story” is about what it feels like to be in love. “Cleveland!” is about what it feels like to have other people watching you be in love.

That shift is part of what has made the song difficult for some listeners to connect with. Hailey Bogetti and Chelsea Zhang, both USC Annenberg public relations master’s students, said the song’s focus on the specific details of Swift’s marriage to Kelce makes it harder to relate to, especially compared with earlier songs that captured feelings listeners could recognize in their own lives.

For Sirjan Sandhu, another Annenberg public relations master’s student, the disconnect comes down to the lyrics themselves.

“I’m a lyrics girl,” she said, pointing to the emotional depth and imagery that once defined Swift’s songwriting. “Lyrics like ‘Now you hang from my lips like the Gardens of Babylon,’ from Swift’s song ‘Cowboy Like Me,’ are meaningful, whereas lyrics from Cleveland like ‘he took me to Cleveland and showed me the heights,’ feel like a departure from what makes Taylor Swift Taylor Swift.”

For listeners like Sandhu, the issue isn’t simply that Swift is writing about her own relationship, but that the lyrics seem to have lost some of the emotional resonance that once made her music so compelling.

Fans on TikTok and in online discussions have made similar comparisons between “Cleveland!” and Swift’s earlier love songs. As International Business Times UK reported, one fan questioned how the songwriter behind “Love Story,” “Enchanted” and “Lover” had arrived at “Cleveland!,” describing the shift as difficult to reconcile with the songwriting they had come to expect from her.

The point isn’t necessarily that Swift is incapable of changing as an artist. It is that the center of her songwriting seems to have moved. A songwriter who was once so internally focused on her own emotional experience now seems increasingly preoccupied with the audience watching her have one.

When the Audience Becomes Part of the Self

There is a sociological explanation for why this dynamic feels increasingly familiar. In her article “Prepare to Pay the Price for Online Celebrity” for USC News, USC sociology professor Karen Sternheimer discusses how social media blurs the line between the public and private self. Drawing on sociologist Erving Goffman’s concepts of “frontstage” and “backstage” behavior, Sternheimer explains how social media makes it increasingly difficult to separate private life from public performance. As she puts it, “Your backstage behavior is no longer just a fleeting moment; it can live on forever.”

That idea feels particularly relevant to Swift, whose clothes, relationships and lyrics are constantly scrutinized for Easter eggs that might reveal something about her life. In a world where almost everything can become a clue for public interpretation, “Cleveland!” suggests something more interesting than simply being watched: the audience has become part of the way Swift experiences herself. The song is not just about what Swift feels; it is about what she thinks other people think she feels.

Maybe that is one of the stranger consequences of celebrity culture: eventually, the gaze of the audience can become part of a person’s own gaze.

For Swift, that phenomenon is unusually visible because the outside world really is watching. But social media has made the experience familiar far beyond celebrity culture. Everyday life now comes with tiny audiences, algorithmic metrics and running comment sections. There are likes to count, stories to check and silences to interpret. It’s become remarkably easy to imagine how a moment looks through someone else’s eyes.

Swift is simply doing it at a much, much larger scale. Maybe that is the strange bargain of being constantly perceived: eventually, the audience isn’t the only viewer. Celebrities can start watching themselves through them.