Just before the Nov. 10 NFL trade deadline, the Los Angeles Chargers decided to trade linebacker Daiyan Henley to the Denver Broncos. In return, the Chargers would receive a fourth-round draft pick in 2027 and a fifth-round pick in 2028, according to ESPN.
At least, that’s what the team intended to do. After the trade was reported, the Broncos backed out of the proposed trade.
When the deal was announced, the Broncos added that the deal was “pending a physical,” according to ESPN. ESPN reported that during this physical, the team found a previously unknown issue with one of Henley’s knees.
In turn, according to ESPN, the Broncos asked for more compensation from the Chargers, and the two teams could not come to an agreement. On Nov. 11, the Broncos posted on their official Instagram account that the trade would not go through.
According to the NFL, the Chargers did not disclose Henley’s injury, although Henley had been listed as having an injury as recently as Week 6.
Henley, a defensive playmaker for L.A., led the Chargers in tackles for the past two seasons. He holds a team record of 51 tackles in eight games, according to ESPN. The two-time team captain started 41 of 56 games in his professional career. According to Chargers writer Omar Navarro, Henley expressed gratitude for his return to the team.
“Shoutout to all of my teammates,” Henley said. “As soon as I got back in the doors, even before I got back in, once I got the information that I was coming back, it was nothing but love and excitement.”
As for the Broncos, the team would have filled a potential missing piece of the puzzle to possibly make a deep run into the playoffs and a Super Bowl title. Broncos head coach Sean Payton praised Henley despite the trade not being completed.
“He’s a prospect we thought – and still do – very highly of. It just didn’t work out,” Payton said on Nov. 16, according to USA Today.
Coach Jim Harbaugh of the Chargers expressed his confusion about how the trade process played out, and shared that the Broncos were able to change their mind because of a loophole.
“In my opinion, it’s one of those loopholes that the league should really look into because it sets a bad precedent, and it continues to set a bad precedent,” Harbaugh said after the trade was nixed.
The loophole relates to the Broncos having the ability to renegotiate rather than just accept or decline the trade after the deadline has passed. This rule only applies if an issue arises from a player’s post-deadline physical, according to the Bleacher Report.
Payton responded directly to Harbaugh on Nov. 16, claiming that it is a byproduct of the trade process.
“There’s no loophole,” Payton said, according to USA Today. “It just is part of the trade process every step of the way.”
Meanwhile, Chargers general manager Joe Hortiz said that the Broncos were aware of Henley’s injury history when the deal was made.
The controversy sparked conversations within the NFL community, specifically within the league’s competition committee, which reviews all competitive aspects of the game. According to Bleacher Report, the committee is expected to discuss alterations to the rules regarding trades.
The announcement prevented what was a rare trade between divisional rivals, though the tale of the season for the two teams could not be more different. The Chargers are currently last place in the AFC West and hold a season record of 0-8. On the other hand, the Broncos are sitting in first at 7-2 on the season.
“[The Chargers] had Super Bowl expectations, and I think basically everyone who follows the team is in shock at the season they’ve had,” said Jeff Moeller, an adjunct professor at the University of Southern California and former public relations director with the Los Angeles Kings.
The reversed trade marks another bump in the road for the Chargers this season, who were likely looking to start a rebuild after this season. NBC reported that the team’s recognition of defeat was one of the driving reasons behind the proposed trade.
“I would say they definitely do need those draft picks,” Lucas Auslen, a senior studying human biology at USC, said. “They need a complete team rebuild at this point.”
Edited by Natalie Cerna
