Annenberg Radio News

Voice actors in the struggle against AI

Voice actors spend years crafting and refining their sound, but what happens when a machine can steal their voice?

Artwork of a robotic hand in a tug-of-war with a person using soundwaves
(Art by Mika Lim)

*Sound of pages flipping and Martinez practicing vocal warm ups*

25-year-old Anthony Martinez is practicing vocal exercises. On most days, he works as a news production assistant at KNX, but when he isn’t doing that, he’s doing this:

*Sound of Martinez voice acting*

He sits in his gray Honda Civic in a grimy underground parking garage in Studio City. The makeshift “studio” is his place of preparation. Rubber ducks sit on the dashboard, while a cross hangs off his mirror next to an anime plushie and a picture of Uma Thurman in “Pulp Fiction.”

Martinez flips through his scripts and practices before he heads to the studio upstairs. Just a few months ago, Martinez decided to take the first step into pursuing a dream of his: voice acting.

Anthony Martinez: Voice acting has always been something that I had been interested in, growing up watching cartoons, animation, you know, all those things. But as I got older, video games were also a really big part of my upbringing.

*Sound of Martinez voice acting*

Martinez hopes to be the kind of actor who can transform his voice to fit the role, and hopes that his heritage can be a part in defining his vocal identity.

Martinez: I do find myself chasing different ways of crafting voices or just different personalities… My ethnicity is Mexican American. I’m Latino myself, and being able to bring that side of myself into a more modern approach where it’s not just that stereotypical Mexican character and anything like that.

But Martinez is also uneasy, as a new shift in the industry looms right as he is getting his foot in the door.

*Audio of AI-generated “Donald Trump” and “Joe Biden” playing “Fortnite”*

Did you catch that? That’s Former President Donald Trump and President Joe Biden playing “Fortnite” together. Or is it? Those voices are AI-generated, and videos like these circled the internet as nothing more than memes. But to voice actors, the rise of AI imitation is a very real fear.

AI is cheaper than hiring an actor. Just shortly after the end of the SAG-AFTRA strikes, the union made a deal with Replica Studios, an AI voice company. The deal allows for the use of AI voice technology to be used in interactive media like video games. And while there are protections like compensation and consent, Martinez is anxious.

Martinez: When I saw the news, I was, if I had to describe it in one word, it would just be disappointing. Just because it kind of felt like… What was the whole point of the strike, if that was going to be the ultimate outcome?

And he’s not alone. Several professional voice actors have gone to social media to express their worries about its use. After all, the deal just opens the door for AI to be used even more in place of real actors.

Christopher Randolph, a voice actor best known for his role as Otacon in the Metal Gear Solid video game series, is among those with reservations. Last October, at the tail end of the SAG-AFTRA strikes, he was already seeing issues involving the use of his iconic voice.

Christopher Randolph: I know that for voice acting for computer games, AI is already here. They can, and I’m starting to learn that actually, there are some websites that actually do imitate my voice… What is more sort of individual and personally owned than our voices and our bodies?

To Randolph, the encroachment of AI into the voice acting space will not only take away from its artistry, but impact those working within the industry.

Randolph: There’s a sort of soullessness to what is created… The very nature of what entertainment is is becoming less and less an actual reflection of what our human condition is, and I think that that’s actually dangerous.

To people like Martinez and Randolph, AI still falls short from the real deal, but its improvement in the long term raises concerns. John De Mita is a voice actor, voice director and a professor at USC. He thinks the use of AI in voice acting is as inevitable as CGI was for movies.

John De Mita: I think that’s the biggest thing that people are afraid of because it involves the absolute elimination of a human being in the process… My opinion is it’s going to become part of what is the business of show business. It isn’t there yet.

Still, De Mita encourages newcomers to push forward, because AI will actually have the least amount of impact on them.

De Mita: The goal of these first pioneers of AI… Their goal is not to ostracize the novice because just completely honestly, they’re the least expensive person in the conversation.

*Sound of Martinez voice acting*

For now, Martinez presses on, putting together his portfolio in hopes of beating the AI wave and achieving his dream to work in a survival horror video game.

Martinez: It’s really just sort of really trying to convince myself that I’m not really necessarily an aspiring voice actor, rather than just telling myself I’m a voice actor.

AI is only getting bigger, and voice actors now have to become more creative to compete in an increasingly automated industry.

For Annenberg Media, I’m Ethan Huang.